Proposed Forum Categories Re-Organization: Please share your thoughts!

Discussion in 'General Community' started by Alex, Nov 5, 2010.

?

Thoughts?

  1. Yes, I vote that we condense some categories and I will reply to this thread with my suggestions.

    66.7%
  2. No, I vote that we leave everything the way it currently is.

    33.3%
  1. Alex

    Alex Community Founder Staff Member

    Good afternoon,

    The time has come to consider the organization of categories for our club forums. I propose that we condense some of the less used forum categories into each other. This will help us reduce clutter, ultimately making them easier to navigate through and participate in. I have created a poll for this thread which contains the following two options: Yes, I vote that we condense some categories and I will reply to this thread with my suggestions; No, I vote that we leave everything the way it currently is. The point is that I value the feedback from everyone. We all use these forums everyday and I want them to be as easy to use as possible. Please take a moment to consider assisting me to help improve and re-structure our forums.

    Below is a complete listing (private categories removed) of the forum structure. Please copy and paste your proposed adjustments. Please do not copy and paste a section if you do not intend to edit it. I wish to keep this thread as clear and concise as possible.

    Current Structure
    --------------------------------------------
    Site News, Announcements & Feedback
    Site Announcements & News
    Site Feedback & Suggestions
    Site Bugs & Problems

    WRXAtlanta Lounge
    New Members / FAQs (1 Sub-Forum)
    Members' Journals
    Lateset Spin (3 Sub-Forums)
    Get-to-Gethers (G2G) (8 Sub-Forums)
    Competition & Motorsports (5 Sub-Forums)
    RSS Feeds

    the Mod Squad
    How-To / Do It Yourself Installs (2 Sub-Forums)
    Engine, Power & Performance (1 Sub-Forum)
    ECU Tuning & Performance Electronics
    Drivetrain
    Handling & Suspension
    Braking
    Tire & Wheel
    Interior & Exterior Styling
    Audio, Video & Security

    Reviews and Buying Advice
    Parts Reviews
    Tech Reviews
    Vendor Reviews
    Dealership Reviews

    The Garage Sale
    Vendor Chat
    Vendor "For Sale" Classifieds
    Vendor Group Buys
    Private "For Sale" Classifieds
    Private "Wanted" Classifieds

    Miscellaneous
    Off-Topic
    Other Makes & Models
    Archives
    --------------------------------------------



    [​IMG]



    Proposed Structure Based on your feedback and my thoughts
    --------------------------------------------
    Site News, Announcements & Feedback
    Community Announcements & News
    Community Feedback & Suggestions
    - [Site Bugs & Problems] Removed: Members may now use bug reporting utility


    WRXAtlanta Lounge
    New Members / FAQs (1 Sub-Forum)
    Members' Journals
    Lateset Spin (Remove all Sub-Forums)
    Get-to-Gethers (G2G) (Remove all Sub-Forums)
    Competition & Motorsports (Remove all Sub-Forums)
    + You've been spotted/sighted!
    - RSS Feeds Removed pending further testing

    the Mod Squad
    How-To / Do It Yourself Installs (2 Sub-Forums)
    - Engine, Power & Performance (1 Sub-Forum)
    - ECU Tuning & Performance Electronics
    - Drivetrain

    + Boxer Engine (2.0L/2.5L), Turbo, ECU Tuning & Drivetrain: Combination of three categories: EPP, Tuning and Drivetrain
    - Handling & Suspension
    - Braking
    - Tire & Wheel

    + Tire, Wheel, Brakes & Suspension: Combination of three categories: H &S, Braking, T & W[/COLOR]
    Interior & Exterior Styling
    Audio, Video & Security

    Reviews and Buying Advice
    - Parts Reviews
    - Tech Reviews
    - Vendor Reviews
    - Dealership Reviews

    + Service (Dealer & 3rd Party), Parts & Tuning Reviews

    The Garage Sale
    - Vendor Chat
    - Vendor "For Sale" Classifieds
    - Vendor Group Buys

    + Sponsor Announcements & Classifieds
    Private "For Sale" Classifieds
    - Private "Wanted" Classifieds: Move back into a more generalize Private FS Classifieds. Take advantage of thread prefixes instead of having additional forums, ex. "Wanted: Begin Thread Title"

    Miscellaneous
    Off-Topic
    Other Makes & Models
    Archives
    --------------------------------------------
    I cannot thank you all enough for your time should you choose to assist me with this. Let's clean this up!

    Regards,
    Alex
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Nov 6, 2010
  2. Alex

    Alex Community Founder Staff Member

    Updating my own list throughout the day :)
     
  3. Alex

    Alex Community Founder Staff Member

    A proposed streamlined and minimalist variant.

    Welcome to the Front Desk
    Community Announcements & News
    Community Feedback & Suggestions
    New Members / FAQs (1 Sub-Forum)
    Service (Dealer & 3rd Party), Parts & Tuning Reviews


    Owners' Lounge
    Latest Spin (3 Sub-Forums)
    Get-to-Gethers (G2G) (Remove all sub-forums)
    Members' Journals
    Competition & Motorsports (5 Sub-Forums)


    the Mod Squad
    How-To / Do It Yourself Installs (2 Sub-Forums)
    Boxer Engine (2.0L/2.5L), Turbo, ECU Tuning & Drivetrain
    Tire, Wheel, Brakes & Suspension
    Interior & Exterior Styling
    Audio, Video & Security


    The Garage Sale
    Sponsor Announcements & Classifieds
    Private "For Sale" Classifieds


    Miscellaneous
    Off-Topic
    Other Makes & Models
    Archives
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Nov 5, 2010
  4. Alex

    Alex Community Founder Staff Member

    Thoughts?
     
  5. b reel

    b reel Active Member

    yeah that f'ing blue has ruined my eye sight
     
    Last edited: Nov 5, 2010
  6. Alex

    Alex Community Founder Staff Member

    Looks fine on the theme I run ;) (Standard out of the box vbulletin) I had to choose a color that stood out and signified an adjustment.
     
  7. b reel

    b reel Active Member

    I'll respond once I learn braille
     
  8. Alex

    Alex Community Founder Staff Member

    What color would you prefer it to be Mr. Keller?
     
  9. superdoughboy4

    superdoughboy4 Active Member

    Not white. Christmas theme here.
     
  10. Alex

    Alex Community Founder Staff Member

    Bout time for me to start working on a new one of those :) Also, removed the blue from the #3 post.
     
  11. b reel

    b reel Active Member

    periwinkle or something calming, soothing
     
  12. superdoughboy4

    superdoughboy4 Active Member

    For the G2G forum, I think you should keep any of the sub-forums that have a fair bit of traffic/posts and get rid of the others.
    But if the case is that all of the sub-forums barely get any traffic, just get rid of them.

    Condensing the forums is a good idea.
     
  13. Alex

    Alex Community Founder Staff Member

    Thank you for the constructive feedback :clap:
     
  14. b reel

    b reel Active Member

    I was just going to suggest a black screen with banner and a button in the center that said "new post" but then I thought that would be over doing it. Didn't see (no pun intended) a reason to add anything as I like your ideas. K.I.S.S.
     
  15. superdoughboy4

    superdoughboy4 Active Member

    Rofl. We can turn it into just a simple message board.
     
  16. Alex

    Alex Community Founder Staff Member

    Wirelessly posted (Mozilla/5.0 (Linux; U; Android 2.2; en-us; Droid Build/FRG22D) AppleWebKit/533.1 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/4.0 Mobile Safari/533.1)

    Ubb?
     
  17. b reel

    b reel Active Member

    isn't that like dead or dying?
     
  18. Alex

    Alex Community Founder Staff Member

    Yeah. I'd never leave vbulletin though ;)
     
  19. Alex

    Alex Community Founder Staff Member

    Bump, was hoping for more suggestions :)
     
  20. Matt

    Matt Think before you post Staff Member Supporting Member

    This is the most constructive post I've ever heard/read from you....
     
  21. Alex

    Alex Community Founder Staff Member

    And the least constructive from you :clap:
     
  22. superdoughboy4

    superdoughboy4 Active Member

    Well, considering half of my posts are in the Off-Topic forum and are made for lulz, there's nothing I can say that's very constructive in the other forums.
    I just read and try to learn.
     
  23. 07Ltd#767

    07Ltd#767 The Neighborhood Drunk

    Allow youtube?
     
  24. jeb

    jeb Member

    ^That was me, on Drews comp, but yeah....
     
  25. 07Ltd#767

    07Ltd#767 The Neighborhood Drunk

    yeah (and this is Drew), embedding would be nice.

    Honestly, though, I vote leave it the same...it's pretty manageable to navigate now, especially when compared to some of the more category intensive sights like nabisco.

    Honestly, though, I just run the darkness theme and search for today's posts every time i log on...keeps all the vendor bumps out and only shows pertinent shit. Doesn't everybody do this?

    *edit* and before you claim security issues...well, there's not.
     
  26. superdoughboy4

    superdoughboy4 Active Member

    Yeah. I don't really browse through the forums anymore. Just click on New Posts and read through everything.
     
  27. Jake

    Jake Active Member

    yeah same here. i just use new posts. except for when im making a post. otherwise. i dont pay attention to the subforums on here much.
     
  28. Alex

    Alex Community Founder Staff Member

    Keep the feedback coming please, thank you.
     
  29. wrxin8or

    wrxin8or Mullitt Staff Member

    I think consolidating would be a good idea. I use either the "New Posts" or "Todays Posts" links for 90% of my surfing here, but when I do need to find a specific thread it is easier to have just main forums instead of 20 different subforums a thread can be under.
     
  30. 07Ltd#767

    07Ltd#767 The Neighborhood Drunk

    another option (and i may be able to change this under user settings, not sure...too lazy to check) to look at would be the forum standard of only showing posts from 1-day or something (at the bottom in individual sub forums). Would be nice if that was 30 days or something...
     
  31. superdoughboy4

    superdoughboy4 Active Member

    There's already an option for that per forum. Not sure if it applies to each and every forum once you apply the settings.
    I've never really found a use for it, and always prefer to have all threads "From the beginning", but it would still be a nice option to have it as a preference.
     
  32. mayoke

    mayoke Member

    Being new to these forums, I unfortunately don't have much input. I'm starting to get used to the layout here but that's not saying it's poorly laid out or anything. I read a lot of forums. ZLOA, GCO, Outdoors Trader, NASIOC, Patriot Guard, etc.

    I do like the "streamlined" layout you suggest in the first post. Thanks for working hard on making this a better place.
     
  33. Alex

    Alex Community Founder Staff Member

    Thanks!

    There isn't much of a way to return from the consolidation short of restoring a database backup. That's the catch and that's something I certainly do not want to do :) I would love to try it out and see...
     
  34. Alex

    Alex Community Founder Staff Member

    The poll is at 10 to 6 for a change. Now is your last chance to voice your opinions or concerns before I try this out over the weekend.
     

Share This Page