I've hit Boost Cut...grrrrrr

Discussion in 'Modifications & DIY how-to' started by ShaneSTI, Oct 14, 2006.

  1. ShaneSTI

    ShaneSTI Active Member

    So a few times In 5th and sometimes 6th gear, I get on it, and "bam!" the car cuts out on me. I basically have ECUTEK, and TBE. Now I thought with EM I won't, or shouldn't get "boost creep" as they call it? So what's the next step? Port the wastegate? Will that fix the problem? I dunno...I'm a little dissapointed in my car right now.:( My "20k" SRT...Neon as they call it didn't do this. Sorry, thats my bitchin for the night about my car.lol
     
  2. crashtke

    crashtke Member Supporting Member

    check the hoses going to the wastegate actuator. I had a leak there and it was spiking bad in 5th and leading to cut out.
     
  3. Slowsoul

    Slowsoul Member

    I'll take it.
     
  4. miloman

    miloman Retired Admin

    STi's with downpipes and the stock VF39 are prone to boost creep in cold weather... datalog the car and post your results... sometimes this effect can be tuned out but sometimes it needs a mechanical fix (port and polish)
     
  5. longfury

    longfury Active Member

    My 04 WRX would have boost spikes after the weather got colder too. I would reset the ECU and it would relearn for the cooler weather. Then all was good and fast.
     
  6. MarkM2016GTI

    MarkM2016GTI Supporting Member

    I remember you telling me about this a few weeks ago Shane....It's still happening huh?. I hope that the problem gets fixed bro...

    Mark
     
    Last edited: Feb 20, 2007
  7. ShaneSTI

    ShaneSTI Active Member

    yeah i already talked to SS, and he's nice enough to offer and load another map in and see if it's better. than if not, eventually when i have the loot...port the wastegate. when is tax season again?lol

    thanks everyone for the advice...yeah i never thought about resetting ECU. i'll try that too, also look for vacume leaks. i REALLY need to get a boost guage.
     
    Last edited: Oct 14, 2006
  8. MarkM2016GTI

    MarkM2016GTI Supporting Member

    February....It will be here in no time..

    Mark
     
  9. clemsonscooby

    clemsonscooby Active Member

    What dp are you running? I've heard that the divorced wastegate pipe really helps to prevent the boost creep. When the turbo is pushing so much exhaust gas right next to the wastegate, the pressure difference really makes the wastegate struggle to open up. I could be wrong, but as a chemist it makes sense to me.
     
  10. siegelracing

    siegelracing Registered Vendor<br><b><font color="#666666">bion

    The divorce actually makes boost creep MORE likely. The wastegate flapper door doesn't open 90 degrees from closed, it's more like 25 to 30 degrees. So if there is divorce plate there, the wastegate flow is right into it. This hampers the flow out of the wastegate, making creep more likely. The bellmouth's are less prone to creep in my experience.

    There is the chance that more aggressive intake-air-temp wastegate duty compensation can prevent the cut, but the only thing that guarantees no creep is porting the wastegate...


    SS
     
  11. Alex

    Alex Community Founder Staff Member

    port your wastegate :p
     
  12. ShaneSTI

    ShaneSTI Active Member

    ^yeah that is what SS suggested. now i just need to come up with $400 bucks.:p that parts and labor. will i get any other performance gains out of port and polishing the wastegate? faster spool up, more HP, ect? i'm still unclear on what this is, but i think this is the route i need to go with.
     
  13. ShaneSTI

    ShaneSTI Active Member

    oops...didn't see this post until i already posted. i have a helix catless dp which is a bellmouth of course. so what other gains, if any besides elliviating (spell) boost creep...if any? i guess the ol' STi is goin back to Scott.lol
     
  14. siegelracing

    siegelracing Registered Vendor<br><b><font color="#666666">bion

    Don't forget, that tweak to the tune only takes 3 minutes and is FREE :D

    SS
     
  15. ShaneSTI

    ShaneSTI Active Member

    oh i haven't forgotten Scott.lol i never forget anything that is FREE.:p i'll definately make it up there this week. i'll be surely to call ya before i head up to see if you're available. thanks again for your help and advice.
     
  16. miloman

    miloman Retired Admin

    scott, can u 'teak' my tune when i get a gt30r?
    :keke:
     
  17. siegelracing

    siegelracing Registered Vendor<br><b><font color="#666666">bion

    I'll be tuning down in Tampa Wed. through Fri... so it needs to be either Monday or Tuesday, or next week. Honestly we are trying to get LOTS done Mon and Tues, so I can drop that map quick, but not spend any time with it. Next week will have a lot more time.

    No problem Milo, it'll just be a "tweak" :D

    SS
     
  18. ShaneSTI

    ShaneSTI Active Member

    okay ss...no worries. next week i'll be in touch. thanx again...shane
     
  19. ShaneSTI

    ShaneSTI Active Member

    man i got owned by boost creep again last night...5th and 6th gear.grrrr i was messing with my Father his 928, and "bam" car cuts out on me. I swear it feels like i'm being kicked backwards. $400 bucks for labor/porting...ugh how hard is it anyways to yank the turbo off? apprx hrs?
     
  20. Alex

    Alex Community Founder Staff Member

    You could DIY, it isnt that complicated. Budget a days effort to pull it port it and put it back in.
     
  21. WJM

    WJM Banned

    Due to scotts limited tuning experience...

    He tweaks.

    ROFLAMOLOL
     
  22. ShaneSTI

    ShaneSTI Active Member

    if i can't mount the turbo back in correctly, and i simply duct tape it back on the manifold? see thats how mechanically inclined i am.
     
  23. goixiz

    goixiz Active Member

    I would think flow in terms of 3 dimensional and not 2 dimensional
    Personally i thnk the plate there reduces the turbulent flow and the wastegate has a less turbulent area to flow into and more of an independent path. unfortunately the pivot pt of the wastegate is on the other side if i were to design a turbo i would want the pivot point on the opposite side. so that when opening the flow of exhaust does not try to hinder the wastegate flow.

    Im not sure porting is worth the trouble i think getting the wastegate to open a tad more is easier to achieve. If you did not preload the WG actuator too much then it will open a tad more.

    How much will ONE pay - to open the wastegate 10-20% more ?
     
  24. Alex

    Alex Community Founder Staff Member

    haha
     
  25. MarkM2016GTI

    MarkM2016GTI Supporting Member

    That's a great point Ming...SS..Great point also...I will take this into consideration if I get Boost Creep. I have a Invidia DP now with the bellmouth.

    Mark:)
     
  26. Cool_____

    Cool_____ Banned

    Hmmmm I'm having the same issues. My solution is an old DSM solution (well maybe not DSM but all the big16g owners like me had to do this), get a big whopping wg flapper and port that bad boy.
     
  27. goixiz

    goixiz Active Member

    porting = $400Porting (parts and labor) = $400
    IxizAntiCreep = $200 Money Back Guarantee w/ FREE WG Chatter eliminator :)
     
  28. siegelracing

    siegelracing Registered Vendor<br><b><font color="#666666">bion

    If you put a more restrictive muffler on (stock, or one like it), it will probably prevent the creep.

    SS
     
  29. Alex

    Alex Community Founder Staff Member

    On the same note, you could keep your foot off the gas.
     
  30. miloman

    miloman Retired Admin

    he could also stop driving the car ;)... but that doesn't seem like a good option
     
  31. Alex

    Alex Community Founder Staff Member

    I didnt say it was a good suggestion, but I wnated to provide one as logical as Siegels restrictive muffler :)
     
  32. Greg

    Greg Active Member

    I get boost creep with a bellmouth and a cat... Only on rare occasions when its really cold
     
  33. goixiz

    goixiz Active Member

    it would be nice to see a log when boost creep happens and what is the WGDC at that moment and the secs leading up to it (hint)
     
  34. kingwrex

    kingwrex Supporting Member

    i also get boost creep, mainly 4th gear when im really pushing it. thats with bellmouth turbo back and manual boost controller. oh, and only when its cold out. my fix is turn boost down
     
  35. siegelracing

    siegelracing Registered Vendor<br><b><font color="#666666">bion

    Mine's not that illogical. Putting a stock muffler on it MIGHT cost 2 whp, but will most likely prevent all creep... so he can use WOT in the cold. It takes 20 minutes to change axle-backs and if he's got his stocker it's free...

    SS
     
  36. goixiz

    goixiz Active Member

    hmmmm so 2 bellmouths so far
    any DWG creeping ???

    Anyone tuned and get consistant Boost Creep
     
  37. siegelracing

    siegelracing Registered Vendor<br><b><font color="#666666">bion

    It's only "terminal mechanical boost creep" if wastegate duty is 0% and it still creeps.

    In my experience (what do I know, I've only tuned 400+ Subaru's) divorced DP's are MORE LIKELY, not guaranteed, and not that belmouth's never do, but MORE LIKELY to cause creep.

    I've seen terminal mechanical boost creep so bad that you could disconnect the wastegate actuator arm from the wastegate and let the flapper swing freely and it still terminally creeps to 21+ psi...

    Loosening an adjustable wastegate actuator arm can have hugely detrimental effects on spool.

    Then again, if you are offering a money back guarantee... (btw, I'll let you in on a little secret, VF-39's don't have adjustable actuator arms like TD04's...)

    SS
     
  38. ShaneSTI

    ShaneSTI Active Member

    i'm really looking for a permanent solution here instead of swapping exhausts. so porting the wastegate is not even a guarantee?
     
  39. goixiz

    goixiz Active Member

    I dont need adjustable arm to open the door wider
    Using stock wastegate arm and actuator arm

    so porting will fix it ?
    blowing thru a trumpet with large mouth(outlet) or a super large mouth (ported)

    Maybe a secondary safety blow off valve that Ts into the stock BOV line
     
    Last edited: Feb 20, 2007
  40. Alex

    Alex Community Founder Staff Member

    I wasnt trying to take a stab at ya, relax :) Anyways, my WG is ported and I have had zero creep over the past year.
     
    Last edited by a moderator: Feb 20, 2007
  41. siegelracing

    siegelracing Registered Vendor<br><b><font color="#666666">bion

    So you are going to charge $200 to bend the arm?

    SS
     
  42. goixiz

    goixiz Active Member

    Pay me $200 and Ill show you the gadget
    If it works i keep the $ if it does not you keep your $

    Bending is for amateurs - absolutely no bending required
    besides bending the arm you are just moving the problem
     
  43. siegelracing

    siegelracing Registered Vendor<br><b><font color="#666666">bion

    Shane, this ^^^ is a deal. You buy this and if it works (and it doesn't have other more detrimental effects) I'll pay you $20 to see it ;) , if it doesn't, then goixiz will give you your money back.

    If there really is a "magic anti-creep "device"" goixiz is going to be RICH. I can point LOTS of creepy STi owners to you for a small fee ;)

    SS
     
  44. Alex

    Alex Community Founder Staff Member

  45. goixiz

    goixiz Active Member

    its a simple solution to a not so complex issue
    all the design things i do daily is simple soulutions and you actually pay considerably more for simplicity. Simple solutions are easy to debug

    But if your turbo is like what SS has seen then no device will help
    (turbo still creeps with WG wide open with wg arm disconnected)

    The "Ixizanticreep" (gadget) uses simple ratio - it uses your OEM stock everything with a totally return to stock concept. Your WGDC still has to be tuned by your tuner like normal. it will just open a % more than stock but preset by the gadget. At the moment i have an idea to make this preset even adjustable (within range). SS, you refer my products and Ill recommend a tune [by SS] after install and we can call it even :)

    Your $ is for machining time and material and for me to have some play money :) to develop other products.

    I dont have a VF39 or any other turbo in the garage so if anyone has one in the in garage and let me borrrow it to verify some dimensions. And if this ever become a production item - Ill give you one for FREE.

    At least you can say you have seen it here FIRST in WRXATLANTA
     
    Last edited: Feb 21, 2007
  46. WJM

    WJM Banned

    oh n03s!!!!!!!!!!!11!!!!!!!!!
     
  47. siegelracing

    siegelracing Registered Vendor<br><b><font color="#666666">bion

    So Shane, this is another "might work" solution. Sometimes going to an EBCS (if you don't already have one) MIGHT work.

    The issue is that the wastegate opening is too small. There's a reason that the new STi turbos, the VF-43s have bigger wastegate openings.

    If this "device" "opens the wastegate more", it will have to be tuned for, or you will be low boost all the time.

    Boost creep is almost entirely temperature sensitive. A car might not do it at all at 50 degrees F, but it can be absolutely terminal (wastagate arm OFF) at 20 degrees.

    So opening it "more" might work at 40 degrees, but will it work at 15 degrees?

    Porting the wastegate is the most proven method, which as far as I know, has near a 100% success rate.

    SS
     
  48. Cool_____

    Cool_____ Banned

    My wastegate is ported to the max from Deadbolt. My exhaust is the culprit. I stick a silencer in the Blitz and the creep stops. On my old B&B exhaust it NEVER creeped. That exhast had wierd baffles in the muffler whereas the Blitz is wide open. I'm breathing a lot more so the back pressure is gone. Deadbolt is gonna put a bigger flapper on the car when I get a chance to remove it but I don't have another vehicle to drive until it gets warmer and I can ride the Harley. However if the creep stops when it warms up I may not worry about it at all.
     
  49. Greg

    Greg Active Member

    :gfight:
     
  50. ShaneSTI

    ShaneSTI Active Member

    Scott...I definately don't have the money to be the guinea pig, and try something new on my car, and see "what happens." The route I'm definately taking is porting the wg out. My tax return should be here soon so I guess I just have to take the plunge and dump another 400 bucks to resolve this. I know you're a busy dude ss, and I appreciate you sharing your experience/knowledge on this issue.
     

Share This Page