Tire Fitment on NEW WHEELS HELP

Alright so i am about to purchase my first set of wheels on my 04 wrx and the wheel specs are

17" x 9" 5x100 / 5X114.3 ET+25 (OR +35)

My question is, my friend is giving me a great deal on

Michelin Pilot Primacy 245 40r 17 91w and i wanna know if thats good enough? Would i have a problem with rubbing issues? I know i have to roll and pull the front and rear fenders a bit?

Any info will help!!!!!! Thanks

 

I would go with 245 35.

 

is it a +25 or +35

i think you may need a slight roll

 

I can get it in +25 or +35

 

I would go with 245 35 but for the price of 4 tires brand new that are 245 40 is the price of 1 tire so i really can't beat the price

 

I also need Lug Nuts, since the oem won't work with the new wheels any recommendations?

 

dont get +25 offset, stick with 35
245/40 is fine
i dont know what suspension youre on so im assuming stock - you MIGHT need a slight roll in the rear but you wont need a pull and you wont need to touch the fronts at all